advertisement
About Advertising Industry

BNET Advertising provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about the major agencies in advertising, marketing, and public relations. In addition to detailed company and agency profiles, we bring you detailed industry analysis on new partnerships and acquisitions, ad buying and cost, new investments, inventory issues, and other issues critical to the marketing sector.

Mommy Blogger Blackmails Crocs Marketer; FTC Poised to Step In

By Jim Edwards | Jul 31, 2009

Mommy bloggers are evil blackmailers who need to be stopped — by the FTC! That is the conclusion of an entertaining piece in Forbes riffing off the news that the FTC is considering regulating blogs for sponsorship or other paid interests, just like regular advertisers.

The item also recounts the tale of George Smith, a social media specialist for Crocs, the clunky, hole-y shoes that are more polarizing than Prof. Henry Louis Gates.

Smith attended the Blogher summit where, he says, he was the subject of a blackmail attempt by a mommy blogger who wanted a free pair of Crocs. Smith had been giving them away to bloggers earlier in the conference but not everyone got a pair. So the woman said:

“Ya know, if you don’t give me shoes – I could totally write something bad about you on my blog.”

“Excuse me?” I asked – hoping she would laugh or give me some indication that she was just joking around. Nope …

“It’s just a pair of shoes. It’s a lot easier to give them to me than deal with the negative press I could make.”

After hearing that, I start to laugh.

“I could pick up my phone here and get in contact with so many people and tell them what just happened that you would be afraid to go near your computer, let alone attempt to blog again.”

BNET was the first of any media to report the FTC’s review, back in November 2008. The Blogher blackmail attempt has kinda caught fire on the web. PaidContent is now calling mommy bloggers “The Devil.”

A thought: Welcome to the real world, mothers who write blogs! You guys had it easy until now. Getting J&J to pull a Motrin ad that suggested — in the nicest possible terms! — that some of you were a little too trendy for your own good lulled you into a false sense of your own power. And now the FTC, along with non-mommy bloggers like Smith, are going to be scrutinizing y’all a bit more closely. Feel free to overeact, moms, as overreaction seems to be your M.O.

Jim Edwards, a former managing editor of Adweek, has covered drug marketing at Brandweek for four years, and is a former Knight-Bagehot fellow at Columbia University's business and journalism schools. Follow him on Twitter or send him an email.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • FTC Blogger Guidelines

    TMC - 41 days 13 hours 17 minutes ago

    Recently the FTC decided that there should be more transparency in blogging (and other new media platforms). So as a blogger I have to spell out my relationship with anyone I write about.  I started as a BellSouth agent in 1999. My disdain for AT&T comes from having to deal with their poor attitude towards agents -- and paying proper...

  • Did the FTC just mention something about blogging?

    Download Squad - 49 days 18 hours 16 minutes ago

    Filed under: Internet , News , Blogging , Microblogging So that we're not the only single blog in the known universe and beyond who misses the chance to comment on the FTC's boneheaded guidelines requiring bloggers, celebs, reviewers and others -- basically anyone who you might read online -- to disclose any "material...

  • This Blog Brought to You by the Federal Trade Commission

    PC World - 47 days 19 hours 25 minutes ago

    Bad news, freebie bloggers: The FTC is coming down on you like a tray of dishes -- and not just on bloggers, but anyone who uses social media

  • The Mother of all Podcasts

    Nuts about Southwest - 139 days 12 hours 48 minutes ago

    Feds Eying The Mommy Blogger-Brand Relationship

    Forbes - 201 days 7 hours 23 minutes ago

    There?s a reason that brands love mommy bloggers. With more moms turning to the web for parenting advice, camaraderie and product recommendations?a favorable review from the likes of bloggers like Dooce, Melinda Roberts or even a less-known mom with a blog can translate directly to an uptick in sales. But with the FTC trying to tackle the issue...

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    sgetgood

    08/03/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Mommy Blogger Blackmails Crocs Marketer; FTC Poised to Step In

    It's unfortunate when the actions of a few, including the unidentified Crocs blackmailer, tarnish the reputations of so many professional, ethical and honest mom bloggers. Women who have been living and writing in the real world for quite some time.

    Polarizing conclusions, such as you make with your opening phrase, only add fuel to the fire. The FTC isn't targeting mom bloggers specifically. It is looking a new forms of paid media, such as street teams, sponsored conversations, and yes, blogs, and evaluating whether the guidelines for commercial endorsements should apply. Moms factor in because they are a demographic of tremendous interest to the consumer products companies, not because they are somehow less ethical as a group.

    It makes good headlines, I suppose. Isn't it time, though, to stop the polarizing debates and refocus on why we blog in the first place?

    That's why 4 women bloggers, myself included, launched blogwithintegrity.com nearly 2 weeks ago. It's a simple pledge that lets bloggers collectively reaffirm our commitment to respect, responsibility and disclosure. To blog with integrity.

    Not as sexy as blackmail perhaps, but far more sustainable.

  •  
    2

    nvineberg

    08/03/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Mommy Blogger Blackmails Crocs Marketer; FTC Poised to Step In

    My experience as a PR practitioner was that several mommy bloggers were happy to write about client products. Each sent a price list for posts that would be written.

    I blame the business people who organized Mommy bloggers into so-called syndicates with the prospect of making some money from ads and paid posts.

    Then I blame the corporations - especially some food manufacturers and their PR firms - who organized paid junkets with the expectation of posts.

    The whole thing stinks and there's lots of evidence of strange play by mommy bloggers. It's not an over-reaction to pursue all kinds of inquiry to put a stop to this 'payola' approach to blogging.

  •  
    3

    mommyinsider

    08/05/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Mommy Blogger Blackmails Crocs Marketer; FTC Poised to Step In

    This is why I think that for the most part, 'mommy bloggers' should not contact PR companies requesting product for review. It's OK to contact a PR company to introduce your blog to them and possibly be added to a media mailing list but this girl should not have demanded or threatened for a pair of Crocs if indeed this is true.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement