About Financial Services Industry

The financial industry meltdown has been the worst since the great depression. BNET Financial provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about the major financial services companies in the banking and finance sector. In addition to detailed company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new mergers, partnerships, financial products, rates, investments, capital, and a host of other critical factors of success in the finance business.

FDIC Chief Sheila Bair to Treasury Brat Geithner: Nyah!

By Alain Sherter | Sep 18, 2009

If this keeps up, Timmy Geithner’s going to take his toys and go home. In a speech at Georgetown University this morning, FDIC chief Sheila Bair reiterated her support for a regulatory council to oversee financial companies and manage systemic risk.

You’ll recall Geithner threw a tantrum last month over other government regulators, including Bair, refusing to line up behind the Obama administration’s plan to hand systemic oversight authority to the Federal Reserve. The Treasury Secretary reportedly swore up a storm in reminding his peers just who’s boss; he did not, I’d like to emphasize, threaten to hold his breath until his pinstripes turned blue.

Looks like the famously spunky Bair didn’t get the message. Giving the keynote address at a conference on the future of global finance, she continued to openly endorse the idea of a regulatory council to protect the financial system (video of her speech is available here beginning at 8:21).

We’re also in need of a regulatory framework that’s proactive, and identifies issues and trends that pose risks to the broader financial system. The new structure, featuring a strong oversight council, would monitor the financial system, from insurance companies to banks. By looking broadly across all of the financial sectors, the council will be able to adopt a “macro-prudential” approach.

The point of looking more broadly at the financial system is that reasonable business decisions by individual financial firms may, in the aggregate, pose a systemic risk. This is a classic “fallacy of composition” problem that cannot be solved by simply making every financial product or practice safe. Instead, rules issued by the council would be uniform for all parts of the regulatory system. The council would monitor how the rules are working and would have the power to take corrective action, if necessary.

In short, an oversight council would see the big picture, with a wide-range of views making it more likely we’d flag the next problem before it causes significant damage.

In other words, bounces off me, sticks on you. Like glue. Bair also delivered a rabbit punch to the government’s financial reform efforts. While praising the Fed’s and Treasury’s actions to stop the meltdown, she also said the measures are perpetuating the “too big to fail” problem by propping up certain large financial players.

Unfortunately, measures taken during the past year — while necessary — have only reinforced the idea that some financial firms are simply too big to fail. Today, we now have fewer players in critical areas of our markets. The market is even more concentrated and interconnected than before. And unless we adopt needed reforms, our system will be more, not less, fragile after this crisis. . . . This has got to stop. We need a credible method for closing large financial companies without inflicting collateral damage on the economy.

You go, girl. And remember, no running in the hallways.

Alain Sherter is an award-winning business journalist who has written for The Deal and Thomson Financial Media.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Sheila Bair

    Forbes - 153 days 7 hours 22 minutes ago

    The FDIC chairman wants a systemic risk council

  • The New Treasury Secretary Builds His Team

    Clusterstock - 296 days 3 hours 32 minutes ago

    Want to know why Tim Geithner is getting rolled by Sheila Bair? The new Treasury Secretary is still at a huge disadvantage when dealing with his Washington DC rival in matters related to the finanical bailout. Bair, the FDIC boss, is one of the few financial regulators who has stayed in place through the change in administrations, which means...

  • Geithner vs Bair

    The Big Picture - 23 days 6 hours 11 minutes ago

    > In the regulatory smackdown between Treasury, and the FDIC, my vote for the saner plan is with the FDIC. Treasury has done a horrific job in overseeing banks, first with Paulson in charge, now with Geithner, who previosuly did a terrible job overseeing banks as President of the NY Fed. My views are pretty straight forward: See, regulation is...

  • Bair Calls for Regulatory Reform

    The Wall Street Journal - 248 days 2 hours 16 minutes ago

    The FDIC's Bair told lawmakers that simply creating a new systemic risk regulator to monitor the broad U.S. financial system is not a cure-all

  • Bair: Without Fee, Fund May Go Dry

    American Banker - 262 days 22 minutes ago

    In a letter dated Monday to chief executives, FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair tried to address criticism of her agency's decision to charge the special 20-basis-point fee at

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    RobertClarkRhodes2

    09/21/09 | Report as spam

    Sheila Bair stands up and is couted...

    It sounds like Ms. Bair is speaking her mind as opposed to mindlessly following the President's lead. I think that Mr. Obama has a plan, but for the U.S. to function well, every head regulator needs to have a brain, use it, and stand up for waht they count as right.

    Mr. Geithner has forgotten this, to my dismay. Even as a very smart guy, he forgot not to pledge allegiance to Obama - he works for the U.S. citizen. Mr. Bush got this way wrong as well, or maybe it was Cheney...

  •  
    2

    Alain Sherter

    09/25/09 | Report as spam

    RE: FDIC Chief Sheila Bair to Treasury Brat Geithner: Nyah!

    Agreed on Bair--tough cookie--and on the need for regulators to contribute to the debate over financial reform, rather than blindly following the program.

  •  
    3

    gsprague

    09/29/09 | Report as spam

    RE: FDIC Chief Sheila Bair to Treasury Brat Geithner: Nyah!

    Secretary Geithner seems to have a certain "edginess" about him most times. Not sure why, maybe because the Treasury Dept. will have to preside over financing of the seemingly miriad, expensive reforms/legislation being proposed by the Obama Administration. If I were he, it would certainly make me a little nervous...

    I, too find it refreshing (maybe even heartening) that Chairman Bair is proposing a regulatory council (sounds like an intra-regulator group) and not simply lining up behind the Secretary's concept of the Fed (Federal Reserve Bank) as the sole regulator. Still, the FDIC is closely related to the Fed; I believe it was founded by the Federal Reserve Act and (paraphrasing relevant FIDC Regulation)functions as a regulatory arm overseeing reserve requirements for depository institutions for the purpose of faclitating implementation of monetary policy by the Fed. So there would be presumed influence between the Fed and FDIC anyway.

    In any case, debate is good, but let's get on with the process...and (hopefully) end up with something that can 1) allow regulators (and financial institutions) to understand and fully appreciate risks posed by financial products and services, and 2) foresee consequences and take appropriate action to correct / change course when needed.

    The sooner, the better; the "innovations" in financial products just keep on coming, the latest examples being CMBS re-Remics and securitized life insurance settlements.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement