AIG's Biggest Victim Could Be Other Life Insurers

Recommended Sources

About Financial Services Industry

The financial industry meltdown has been the worst since the great depression. BNET Financial provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about the major financial services companies in the banking and finance sector. In addition to detailed company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new mergers, partnerships, financial products, rates, investments, capital, and a host of other critical factors of success in the finance business.

Let’s get serious. The lynch mob that’s out to hang those American International Group (AIG) executives with their $165 million in bonuses is going to fail.

First of all, their rope is too short to reach across the Atlantic Ocean. The fat bonus checks have already been delivered to traders in AIG’s Financial Products unit, which is based in London. Chances are these Brits are now at the pub, three sheets to the wind, laughing at the outrage from across the pond that they are viewing on the telly. So playing the shame game by naming them, as New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo suggests, isn’t going to work.

And neither are legal measures. The contracts are valid. For the U.S. itself to break a contract would be equivalent to defaulting on a Treasury bond. And that’s not going to happen.

So who is going to get hurt? Quite possibly other insurers, and particularly life insurers. It is no secret that 12 lifers are lined up, tin cup in hand, looking for money from the TARP (Troubled Asset Relief Program) fund. Frank Keating, president of the American Council of Life Insurers, refuses to name names, but they are apparently some of the biggest, including Prudential and Hartford. Earlier in the month Keating suggested that action could come “in the next several weeks.”

Will they get a blank check from the Treasury the way AIG did several months ago? Not bloody likely. Their argument, as reported on BNET Financial in January , is that they’ve taken huge losses on their investment portfolios and need to shore up their capital in order to pay claims. But that soap did not wash when they took their complaints to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the quasi-regulatory body for the U.S. insurance industry, back in January.

The NAIC, led by New York State Insurance Superintendent Eric Dinallo, turned them down. Are they expecting a better reception from a Congress, president and treasury secretary already battered for letting AIG get away with so much? The life insurers may want to insure themselves; the lynch mob is heading their way.

Tags: American International Group Inc., Insurance Company, Chances, Insurance, Business Operations, Corporate Insurance, Ed Leefeldt

Ed Leefeldt is an award-winning investigative and business journalist who has worked for Reuters, Bloomberg and Dow Jones, and is the author of The Woman Who Rode the Wind, a novel about early flight.

BNET User Analysis

Voice your 2cents

Web Buzz:

ANALYSIS: Current Bush Tax System Saves AIG Traders More Than $7.5 Million Per Year

Wonk Room - 252 days 1 hour 43 minutes ago

Bailed-out insurance giant AIG just revealed that they would be paying over $165 million to traders "in the very group that caused the company to fail." Lucky for these traders, they're collecting their bonuses under the Bush tax system that lowered income tax rates for the richest 2 percent of Americans. According to our analysis, thanks to the...
Executive-level scapegoats

Globe and Mail - 250 days 16 hours 54 minutes ago

Toronto -- I was surprised that Margaret Wente joined the "blame-it-all-on-AIG-execs" lynching mob and the populist outcries from both sides of U.S. politics demanding that even bonuses already paid should be returned or taxed away (Obama's Exploding Cigar - March 17). She suggests that even though the bonuses may have been contractual...
AIG Paid Three Times More In Bonuses than Originally Announced

Seeking Alpha - 202 days 5 hours 8 minutes ago

Tyler Durden submits: Let's recall what the magical bonus number was that caused Barney Frank to almost get a lynch mob armed and ready to march on Wall Street: $165 million in retention bonuses. So one would expect Barney's anger would be three times as high when the actual
House approves 90% tax on AIG bonuses

MarketWatch - 250 days 4 hours 53 minutes ago

WASHINGTON (MarketWatch) -- Responding to the anger over $165 million in bonuses paid to AIG traders, the House approved a bill Thursday that would impose a punitive 90% tax on bonuses paid by American International Group Inc.and other financial companies that receive federal help. The vote was 328-93, with about half of the Republicans joining...
Some AIG executives return bonuses -- WSJ

MarketWatch - 245 days 18 hours 40 minutes ago

SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) -- Three-fourths of the top recipients of $165 million in bonuses handed out to executives at American International Group Inc. (AIG:AIGNews , chart , profile , moreLast:Delayed quote dataAdd to portfolioAnalystCreate alertInsiderDiscussFinancialsSponsored by:, , ) have agreed to give the money back, according to a...