About Media Industry

BNET Media provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives in publishing, print, broadcast, film, and online media. In addition to media company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new partnerships, media products, mergers and acquisitions, labor and cost management, media buying, investments and a host of other important business issues.

Experts: Twitter is the Game-Changer

By David Weir | Jul 16, 2009

Pasadena, CA. Earlier today, during a meeting in Silicon Valley, I spoke with two exceptionally talented executives, both of whom have had long, successful careers with tech/media companies big and small, and both of whom have been extremely active online since the earliest days of the web.

One is an expert in technology, whose innovations have affected users the world over; the other, a leader in communications, with a A List of contacts in and out of the biggest and coolest companies inside the Valley and beyond. I’m sorry I cannot name them here, but suffice it to say they was an education of the highest order for your simple Bnet Industries blogger just to be present.

The conversation quickly turned to Twitter and whether it was a passing fad or here to stay.

“Twitter is exactly what the Internet was around 1996,” said the first man. “It represents nothing less than the New Internet. It is the game-changer.”

“It is growing exponentially, just as the Internet did after Tim Berners-Lee invented the web,” said the second. “And its growth is global in scope, which will prove to be significant.”

“What will come next,” said the first, “will be that all the things we saw in the mid-’90s. They need to be re-invented for Twitter. Search and all other functionalities have to be developed to sit on top of Twitter, just as they once had to be invented to sit on top of the web browser.”

“There needs to be a Yahoo for Twitter, i.e., the organization of all historical knowledge, the master index, the portal,” noted the second.

“Yes!” said the first emphatically, “and in fact, these tools are already coming. There are at least 7,000, maybe many more APIs, running on top of Twitter. Thousands of entrepreneurs are trying to build the ‘killer app.’ Some will succeed, most will fail.”

“The next Xbox 360 will have Twitter,” noted the second. “This will begin to bring in the younger generation, who so far have not adopted Twitter — but they will.”

Then, he paused for a moment, considering what the proper analogy would be for this precise moment in the develop of social media. “You know, it was really the hypertext link that defined the emergence of the web as a superior platform for interactive communication. And there is already an equivalent on Twitter — the hash tag. When you think about it, the @ symbol came to define the Internet in the 90s; today the # symbol defines the emergence of social media. It’s funny, two simply keys on any keyboard and they carry so much importance for all of us, and for the future.”

The conversation went on, turning to Microsoft’s inclusion of Tweets on Bing, and Google’s coming “Wave,” and the need for a certain convergence between Wikipedia and Twitter. But this is as much of the conversation as I feel comfortable divulging at this point, since there were several proprietary issues that then came to the fore.

I’ve had similar conversations with dozens of people the past few months, but rarely with anyone I respect more than these two. Every day, of course, I also hear from skeptics, who dismiss Twitter as just the latest in a long series of shooting stars.

My own instincts were to classify Twitter that way until earlier this year, when I began to notice the astonishing power of real-time information. Since I blog from a business perspective, part of my skepticism was also based in Twitter’s lack of any recognizable business model.

The best evidence suggests that over the next few months Twitter’s elusive business model will in fact emerge.  And it appears to be potentially an extremely lucrative one. But now, if you wll excuse me, I’ve got to get back to my Twitter feed…

In addition to serving as a BNET Media analyst/blogger, David Weir is a veteran journalist and the author of several books. Weir is a co-founder and vice-president of the Center for Investigative Reporting, as well as an editorial board member of The Nation.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Will China Innovation Work?

    Global Neighbourhoods - 77 days 11 hours 30 minutes ago

    I have been watching with a great deal of interest the departure of Kai-Fu Lee from Google to form Innovation Works, which has aggregated a $115 million fund that will be invested in tech start ups. While $115 million is not enormous anymore by Silicon Valley private equity standards, that amount will go many times further in China and should be...

  • SDForum Open Innovation and Corporate Research Fair

    VentureBeat - 67 days 11 hours 48 minutes ago

    SDForum, Silicon Valley’s leading source of information and education in the technology community announces its Second Annual Open Innovation and Corporate Research Fair to be held September 18, 2009, from 8:30am - 3:00pm at The Techmart in Santa Clara, CA. Instituting continuous innovation is a daunting challenge at technology companies;...

  • Mossberg, Swisher, AllThingsD Get An iPhone App

    Silicon Alley Insider - 190 days 1 hour 1 minute ago

    There's no shortage of news apps on the iPhone -- the AP, Reuters, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, and dozens of other major publications have published apps for Apple's (AAPL) phone. But here's a new one that's focused on tech: the new AllThingsD app from News Corp./Dow Jones. Like the AllThingsD Web site , the free...

  • Y Combinator's AngelConf Teaches Would-Be Investors How To Get Started

    Tech Crunch - 283 days 18 hours 43 minutes ago

    It's no secret that Silicon Valley is teeming with wealthy tech veterans, many of whom are eager to try their hand at angel funding a few new startups. Unfortunately, the vast majority of them are put off by the logistics of figuring out exactly what they're supposed to do (handing out money isn't as easy as it sounds). In light of this, Paul...

  • Bumbling around and failing every which way . . . lessons for success

    ZDNet - 147 days 23 hours 54 minutes ago

    Vinod Khosla is one of Silicon Valley’s most successful VCs. I was at the recent SDForum Visionary Awards where Mr Khosla was one of four winners of the 2009 awards. His acceptance speech was short and very good. Excellent advice for entrepreneurs. Also, he talks about failure, which I have long advocated is Silicon Valley’s strength. A...

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    TheNudger

    07/17/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Experts: Twitter is the Game-Changer

    Thanks for sharing the insights, David. My take on what they are saying is that Twitter is now extremely labor-intensive - in the way the Internet was in 1996. To me, using Twitter is like reading microcode - effective but painstaking and really time consuming. Fatigue will set in (it has for me) unless effective organizational tools (like Tim's hyperlinks) arrive soon. You see this perspective in some of the stories that debate the claim that social media is "free" - arguing that it certainly isn't if you value your time!
    I question the Yahoo! analogy, in the sense that it's not clear how much actual knowledge there is in the Twitter stream. There is certainly lots of chatter, some information, and bit of actual insight now and them. But to me, the next great thing for Twitter users is less a way order lots of clearly useful stuff (like the Web or Wikipedia) and more a way to dig out the small amount of signal from an aincreasingly overwhelming amount of noise without having to monitor the stream 24/7. Hastags are a start, but being voluntary and unstructured, they provide no consistent and reliable organizational heirarchy right now.
    In terms of Twitter containing historically valuable knowledge - try this exercise. Take everything you have learned from Twitter, and go to Wikipedia and add it. How much have you really improved on the knowledge already there? That may change with time, but I doubt it. IMHO, Twitter will end up more as a super high gain amplifier of what's already known than a source of new knowledge.

  •  
    2

    hotweir

    07/17/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Experts: Twitter is the Game-Changer

    Thanks for your comment. I agree that the mighty Tweet stream contains tons of drops of water that, taken alone, mean virtually nothing. Sort of like tons of emails. Collectively, however, they represent real-time information that can move mountains (or more to our point, make fortunes.)

    Virtually lost in the stream are hidden gems: People whose Tweets are incredibly good and worthwhile. These people break news or add perspective that is unique and timely. Sometimes, they bring great passion to their work, not to mention humor, insight, and inspiration.

    Check out "The Expert." His bubble tweets are a constant source of amazement and inspiration for me. These are the kinds of voices that will need to be raised out of the main stream by new tools, such as a Yahoo directory service.

    In other words it is the people Tweeting who interest me more than the Tweets themselves, which by format, are of course limited to 140 characters -- more like little shout outs!

  •  
    3

    TheNudger

    07/17/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Experts: Twitter is the Game-Changer

    Great point that is applicable to life in general too. Think about receptions and cocktail parties - mostly noise and bad food, but now and then a gem of a person/conversation appears. The time and energy it takes to participate is, however, not insignificant.
    I do expect a Twitter fatigue factor to kick in if really useful efficiency tools don't appear soon. Many corporate people I know were excited at first to use social media/news and then Twitter, but they are now complaining about how much more time and effort it takes to get a return, and how that return is often less than they got before when they just fired off print ads and waited until their PR people came back with the performance data.
    Some argue that the short and quick nature of Tweets makes it easier to watch/respond. That's true, but it comes with a pretty high price - now essentially every waking moment is fair game. I have some good friends I can't stand to be around anymore because of their incessant Tweeting. Because of the need to compose clever repartee for their audience of followers, it seems they have even less bandwidth available for the present real conversation than when they were just texting or responding to email.
    Maybe I'm just old and in the way, but I seem much more resistant these days to things that "only demand time". Time is, in the end, all we have, and we should spend it wisely.

    Nick D.

  •  
    4

    hotweir

    07/17/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Experts: Twitter is the Game-Changer

    Well said. As much as I cover Twitter here, and share the perspective that it is altering the landscape, not only in the media industry but broadly across the board, I cannot spend much time on it myself.

    There is way too much else I must do, research to be conducting, SEC filings to be reviewed, interviews conducted. I could post a list of the ten best Twitter apps but it would probably be out of date by the time I clicked "publish."

    As for Twitter Addiction, I'd counsel moderation to those friends of yours!

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Click Here
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement