About Media Industry

BNET Media provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives in publishing, print, broadcast, film, and online media. In addition to media company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new partnerships, media products, mergers and acquisitions, labor and cost management, media buying, investments and a host of other important business issues.

Someone, Quick, Place the AP on Suicide Watch

By David Weir | Aug 2, 2009

This really has to be seen to be believed. For whatever reason, the Associated Press’s official form for collecting fees ranging from $12.50 to $100 if you want to republish as a link more than four words from any of its headlines had eluded my view until this evening, even though Danny Sullivan linked to it in a blog post almost three months ago.

The context here is that AP has been making a lot of noise about its “wrapper software” that will supposedly allow it to ferret out those evil content thieves who are allegedly reprinting entire AP articles without paying for the right to do so. It’s also been making threats against Google that may well come back to bite the wire service in the ass when it next sits down to renegotiate its licensing fee contract.

Tonight, as a little exercise, and squarely within my rights under the “Fair Use” doctrine, I am now going to “republish,” i.e., link to,  three AP headlines under its “Top News” tab.

Now, if the AP’s own form is to be interpreted literally, I would either need to shorten these three headlines to:

  • Sands hit fate of…
  • American with cold misses…
  • AP sources: Military-civilian…

…or pay the AP $37.50 for the right to drive it traffic! Are you effing kidding me? It appears that my colleague Erik Sherman may have been right when he posed the question recently, “Is AP Run by Idiots?

I kinda feel like Rachel Maddow of CNN, and her “Somebody please talk me down” construct. Maybe — hopefully — I am misinterpreting what the AP is trying to do here. If so, I hope someone out there will educate me, so I can correct the record. Meanwhile, since I’m not going to be holding my breath for that, here are links to our recent coverage of the insanity at AP here at Bnet:

July 27 The AP, Publishers, Battle an Imaginary Army of Pirates

“Like other bloggers, my initial response was that the AP’s management must be made up of nincompoops. While that may well be true, I’m not sure that what the wire service is proposing will actually have any effect on what those of us who follow “Fair Use” practices do when we cite AP content…”

July 27 Hey AP: Here Are 7 Money-Making Ideas for You (By Erik Sherman)              “Last week, I suggested that the Associated Press was run by idiots, not because I have anything in particular against them, but because management seems intent on doing things that will ultimately doom the organization…”

July 24 Print News Media to the Rest of Us: Somebody’s Gotta Pay (By Cathy Taylor)    “Two stories this morning point out how desperate the print news business is to get someone to pony up cash for their product…”

June 13 AP Will Distribute Non-Profit Investigative Groups’ Stories
“The Associated Press announced today that it will begin distributing investigative reports from four nonprofit news organizations to its member newspapers beginning next month…”

June 1 High Stakes Battle Lines Drawn: The AP v. Yahoo!
“Yahoo’s ongoing experiment with newspapers to sell behavioral-targeted and geo-coded advertising may help determine whether a “hyper-local” business model can be established to go along with the geo-coded content model…”

April 15 AP Shows Up ~ a Decade Late for the Portal Party
“Earlier today, my Bnet colleague Erik Sherman, who has been following the AP’s moves from a technology Industry perspective, suggested that the AP appears to be intent on creating its own news portal…”

Apr. 6 Panicky AP Lashes Out at The Internet
“It didn’t take long — just three days — after a well-reasoned argument proposing that the Associated Press is partly to blame for destroying the newspaper business for the AP to react…”

Apr. 3 Is AP to Blame for Killing Newspapers?
“There’s a new party getting blamed for the death of newspapers — the good-old Association Press. The line of reasoning goes like this: By allowing Yahoo, MSN, Google and others access to its news wire, the non-profit news cooperative is undermining the very companies that own it…”

Mar. 30 AP’s Loss and HuffPost’s Gain
“It would be hard to find two items that, when juxtaposed, better capture the zeitgeist in the media industry than these two from this morning’s emailbag…”

In addition to serving as a BNET Media analyst/blogger, David Weir is a veteran journalist and the author of several books. Weir is a co-founder and vice-president of the Center for Investigative Reporting, as well as an editorial board member of The Nation.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Tell ‘im he’s dreamin’: AP quote $2.50 per word$

    Crikey - 108 days 19 hours 46 minutes ago

    Wire Service The Associated Press don't like people getting something for nothing, and are now charging websites and news outlets to quote from its articles, with prices ranging from $12.50 for five words to $100 for 251 words or more

  • Obama Is A "Miserable Failure" [Voices]

    Wall Street Journal - 301 days 14 hours 39 minutes ago

    I told you so. Or I told anyone who cared. I even tried to reach the Obama administration in four or five different ways. Do a search on Yahoo (YHOO) right now for miserable failure, and you'll find President Barack Obama's page ranking either in the top spot or the second spot. Given a redirect that Obama's web team has put into place, he...

  • Associated Press: We Are Not Targeting Bloggers

    Mashable - 109 days 1 hour 5 minutes ago

    Yesterday, we brought to light that the Associated Press had begun charging for the republishing of its articles, starting at $2.50 per word. The news was heavily shared and came to as a shock to many, if the 80+ comments in our last article is any indication. Today, the Associated Press reached out to us to clarify their position on...

  • Top WordPress Contact Form Plugins

    Website Magazine - 121 days 18 hours 25 minutes ago

    You'll never convert anyone from a browser to a buyer if they can't contact you! While there are loads of online form providers (I typically recommend FormSpring and Wufoo), there are lots of ways to collect user data. Here are the top five WordPress contact form plugins. Did we miss one? Let us know by commenting below.  Contact... [[ This...

  • Reuters Tells AP: “Stop Whining”

    Mashable - 106 days 8 hours 58 minutes ago

    The Associated Press has been making controversial moves in the online space recently, including a plan to charge $12.50 for quoting 5 words of an AP story and enforcing strict social media rules on its staff. The AP has also been very critical of Google , as it sees this new news eco-system cutting into its business. The moves...

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    Joeholl

    08/03/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Someone, Quick, Place the AP on Suicide Watch

    If the cost is too high, write your own material.

  •  
    2

    S.Howard-Sarin

    08/03/09 | Report as spam

    Well, you could always link to CBS

    Here's another twist: BNET is owned by CBS Corp. CBS pays the AP for the right to publish AP stories. So, David could skip around the whole issue of fair-use linking and "quoting" headlines by using CBS's paid-for versions:

    American With Cold Misses Ill-fated Hike Into Iran (on CBSNews.com)

    American With Cold Misses Ill-fated Hike Into Iran (on CBS' local TV station in San Francisco)

    American With Cold Misses Ill-fated Hike Into Iran (on CBS' local TV station in Ohio)

    Etc.

    Do we have to pay to point to stuff we've already paid for?

  •  
    3

    hotweir

    08/03/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Someone, Quick, Place the AP on Suicide Watch

    Thanks, Howard, presumably you are right, and of course I was just trying to illustrate the Fair Use issue -- not for me, or Bnet -- but for the everyday user out there. The tone of my posts may become even more desperate because I don't want the AP to fail. But they seem to not be listening.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Click Here
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement