About Media Industry

BNET Media provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives in publishing, print, broadcast, film, and online media. In addition to media company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new partnerships, media products, mergers and acquisitions, labor and cost management, media buying, investments and a host of other important business issues.

Amra Tareen's AllVoices: "Bottom-Up Media"

By David Weir | Feb 5, 2009

Fifteen floors above the financial district in downtown San Francisco, through a pair of unmarked double doors and past a maze of mostly uninhabited cubicles, Amra Tareen is determined to change the world — from the bottom up.

A skeptic might question how much a well-heeled Harvard MBA, with a successful background in venture capital and technology companies, would know about the communication needs of the world’s poorest people, those whose voices are virtually never heard through conventional media channels.

But that would only be a skeptic who hadn’t yet met Amra Tareen. A tall, strikingly beautiful woman with wild hair, boundless energy, and a speaking style reminiscent of the water pouring over Niagara Falls, Tareen is less an entrepreneur than a pure force of nature. Her tiny company, AllVoices.com, may be only six months old, but with 1.3 million unique monthly visitors in over 100 countries, she is off to a strong start toward living up to her corporate logo, “The first open media site where anyone can report from anywhere.”

Tareen’s inspiration for All Voices came partly after the devastating earthquake in her native Pakistan in 2005. As a volunteer with Relief International, she witnessed first-hand the resilience of the poor women, widows and orphans she met when they were offered sources of micro-credit to rebuild new lives. “This inspired me to start a company that would let people no matter where they were to write about what they knew about an event, upload photos, videos, and write their stories and views and share with the rest of the world,” she says.

Tareen is also keenly aware that as a Muslim woman living in the West, unveiled, highly educated, successful, married to a white American and mother of two, that she can act as a symbol to help break down the anti-Islamic bias that permeates American culture, as well as much of mainstream media. Not only that, as an ethnic Pathan, the largest “segmental lineage” (tribal) society in the world, she represents the other side of a people who have given the world the Taliban, the lawless provinces of the Afghan-Pakistan border region, and safe harbour for Osama bin-Laden and al-Qaeda.

Not one to move slowly, Tareen has already built All Voices into a robust content platform with articles and perspectives available nowhere else on the web that I am aware of. Even a cursory look around the site reveals datelines from such a wide variety of places — Eskişehir,Turkey; Jaba’, Palestine; Fayetteville, Ark.; Dera Ghāzi Khān, Pakistan; Sunan, North Korea; and Sheboygan, Wis. — that you’d be hard-pressed to find a more truly global news service anywhere.

Most of the articles come from “citizen reporters,” whose posts are then contextualized with other perspectives imported from mainstream media, blogs, YouTube, and all manner of SMS via RSS and other feeds. “We give the users a way to create a rich, multimedia content page that is really an event,” explains marketing chief Aki Hashmi. “It’s quite natural, then, that they want to share these events with their friends, so we are growing virally very quickly, without any marketing spend at all.”

Writers who want to earn money on the site, which Tareen dubs “the CNN of the people,” can do so by building page views — $100 for every 10,000 PV’s at present. “We’ll find other ways to compensate them, also,” Tareen says, noting that a share of the advertising revenue that is the main business model underlying the site is not out of the question.

All Voices is built on several layers of technology developed under the supervision of some of the leading experts in information retrieval and computer sciences from Northwestern, Stanford, and the private sector. All text is geo-coded, categorized, and analyzed for keywords.

None of this user-generated content is censored or edited, which leads me to note a potential red flag that could slow down The Amra Express. Left to their own devices, users will inevitably introduce unsavory content to the site, as well as spam comments, flaming, swarming, porn and all the other content detritus so prevalent online.

It would seem that All Voices will need human community managers, hosts, coaches, editors to set the right tone and keep the content on track if this is really going to reach the scale that Tareen told me she is seeking: “All six billion people on the globe.”

Sounds grandiose, but I wouldn’t bet against Amra Tareen. She has the vision, idealism, drive, resources and charisma to transform her dream into reality, even though there’s going to be a lot of heavy lifting to get from here to there.

Thank you to Junko Sasaki for help with this post.

In addition to serving as a BNET Media analyst/blogger, David Weir is a veteran journalist and the author of several books. Weir is a co-founder and vice-president of the Center for Investigative Reporting, as well as an editorial board member of The Nation.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Papercraft NES and Dreamcast cost less, play just as many cutting edge games

    Engadget - 114 days 10 hours 54 minutes ago

    Finally, your lovingly prepared SNES model is getting some well-heeled new friends to hang out with. Cubeecraft is a website wholly dedicated to the paper-based recreation of cultural icons, and it's prepared a pair of exquisitely detailed clones of the NES and Dreamcast. While some such projects might require patience and finesse ,...

  • Billboard for WWDC is torn down; startup smells rotten Apple

    ZDNet - 164 days 11 hours 16 minutes ago

    The co-founders of a small startup suspect something more than a dark subway stairwell prompted a billboard to be pulled from a downtown San Francisco wall before the crowd attending Apple’s Worldwide Developer Conference could see it Monday morning. That billboard, which was leased by a company called doubleTwist and contained an ad with the...

  • Mayfair says 'goodbye' to good old days of soaring rents

    Times Online - 313 days 11 hours 12 minutes ago

    For a decade it was the preferred location for hundreds of hedge fund managers as they deserted the City and set up shop nearer to their well-heeled clients. Making the move to Mayfair and St James's, they would think nothing of paying more than £100 a square foot for a few floors inside a Georgian townhouse, driving rents ever higher as they...

  • Civilians in space: FAQ

    CBC News - 242 days 15 hours 16 minutes ago

    From right, Hungarian-born U.S. software designer and space tourist Charles Simonyi, Russian cosmonaut and crew commander Gennady Padalka and U.S. astronaut Michael Barratt pose together in Baikonur, Kazakhstan, March 21, 2009. The crew is to blast off for the international space station from the Baikonur cosmodrome on March 26 in a Russian-made...

  • In Line at the iPhone 3GS Launch

    Wired - 154 days 18 hours 8 minutes ago

    SAN FRANCISCO — The line to purchase an iPhone 3GS was short and sweet this morning at the downtown San Francisco Apple store. When the doors opened at 7am, the queue stretched down the block and was maybe 150 humans deep. Unlike previous years, there were relatively few Apple acolytes camped out in line overnight

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    girlypooo

    02/07/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Amra Tareen?s AllVoices: ?Bottom-Up Media?

    A couple of corrections and thoughts:

    Allvoices went live in Nov 07
    http://www.alexa.com/data/details/traffic_details/allvoices.com

    here is an article on allvoices.com from December 2007:
    http://amumtaz.wordpress.com/2007/12/29/allvoicescom-a-refreshing-approach-to-news-and-events/

    and officially launched when Amra went to Pakistan in Feb 08.
    http://www.allvoices.com/blog/344268

    Though those press releases they put out have been wiped from their own site.

    Allvoices also got caught trying to pay journalism grad students to seed its community for comments and spamming Reddit.
    http://www.thestandard.com/news/2008/11/18/allvoices-com-wants-pay-journalists-story-comments#comment-8556

    It would be nice if Allvoices succeeds but if they continue to be dishonest (telling you they launched 6 months ago, when in fact it was a relaunch after the prior 6 month launch), it may mean growing a community the right way is beyond their abilities.

  •  
    2

    hotweir

    02/09/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Amra Tareen

    Thank you for your comment, girlypooo -- it was my oversight that led to not mentioning the earlier history...they mentioned it but called it a beta phase, so I ignored it. But the attempt to game Redditt was something I was not aware of. You raise an excellent point about growing communities. Many companies try to find shortcuts, but these rarely work. A true community grows much more slowly than VC's can tolerate -- I suspect that is what causes these things to occur, although I don't know about this specific case. I posted an article over the weekend about Village Voice Media gaming Digg. It is not wise for companies to do this, because they will eventually be outed and embarrassed.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement
Click Here