About Pharma Industry

BNET Pharma provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about major manufacturers of pharmaceuticals and medicine. In addition to detailed drug company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new partnerships, drug patents and products, cost management, investments, pharmaceutical related lawsuits, and a host of other important business issues.

Peter Pitts' CMPI Targeted Over Anti-Healthcare Reform Video Game

By Jim Edwards | Nov 20, 2009

The Center for Medicine in the Public Interest is a “corporate front group” that sponsored the near-riots at town hall meetings on healthcare and spreads misinformation about healthcare reform, according to a report by ThinkProgress, a liberal blogging group. It even produced an anti-reform video game, “Super Race to the Hospital,” the site alleges.

CMPI’s anti-reform agenda dovetails neatly with its links to PR group Porter Novelli, PN’s corporate parent Omnicom (OMC) and its health insurance clients, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Health Insurance Plans of New York and HealthNet, TP claims.

Pharma bloggers have long speculated (off the record, that is) about the possibility of a “takedown” of CMPI and its DrugWonks blog. The blog, written by CMPI chief Peter Pitts and Robert Goldberg, takes a stridently conservative line (sample headline: “The Junk Science of Obamacare“). It recently defended the pharmaceutical business over its recent drug price rises, for instance. It appears that TP’s Lee Fang has finally put the effort in.

For industry watchers, one of the more gossipy bits focuses on how Pitts earns his living:

In March of this year, Pitts became the head of international corporate PR firm Porter Novelli’s healthcare division. Despite the fact that CMPI’s latest 990 tax form states that Pitts spends 40 hours a week at CMPI, a representative from Porter Novelli told ThinkProgress that Pitts actually works on a day to day basis in his office at Porter Novelli. Asked about how the firm engages in the health reform debate, ThinkProgress was told by Porter Novelli that Pitts is “pretty much our voice.”

If you read it closely, you’ll find that there’s less there than meets the eye, but it’s presented as some sort of conspiracy. Did anyone not know that Pitts works for both PN and CMPI? It also rehashes the whole Eli Lilly/NPR/Infinite Mind episode. Pitts told BNET tha the author did not call him for comment prior to publishing the piece. He added:

So many errors and so silly.

My favorite part is the revelation that CMPI produced an anti-healthcare reform video game. Called “Super Race to the Hospital,” players must steer an ambulance to the ER while avoiding Big Gummint roadblocks. It’s slightly less sophisticated than Pfizer (PFE)’s aborted Viagra “Viva Cruiser” game.

Jim Edwards, a former managing editor of Adweek, has covered drug marketing at Brandweek for four years, and is a former Knight-Bagehot fellow at Columbia University's business and journalism schools. Follow him on Twitter or send him an email.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • NYC Travel Chaos Continues [Travel Nightmares]

    Gawker - 48 days 11 hours 55 minutes ago

    Yesterday at JFK, a near-riot . Today at Penn Station , no trains to or from NJ

  • If the Science is There, Obama Says He Will Back Complementary & Alternative Therapies

    Nutrition Business Journal - 280 days 9 hours 58 minutes ago

    When Barack Obama was asked by a licensed acupuncturist and massage therapist during an April 29 town hall meeting how complementary & alternative medicine will fit into his healthcare agenda, the president said he is an advocate for doing what works. “I think it is pretty well documented through scientific studies that acupuncture, for example

  • Here's a First: Man Arrested For Not Using Twitter [MediaMemo]

    Wall Street Journal - 79 days 13 hours 59 minutes ago

    Terrifying? Inevitable? Harbinger? In any case, it’s a first: Police in Long Island, New York have arrested a man for not using Twitter. Someone named Justin Bieber, who apparently is a teenage singer, was supposed to appear at the Roosevelt Field mall on Friday, but didn’t because the crowd had become too unruly. Police asked a record label...

  • Man Arrested For Not Using Twitter

    Silicon Alley Insider - 79 days 11 hours 19 minutes ago

    Terrifying? Inevitable? Harbinger? In any case, it’s a first: Police in Long Island, New York have arrested a man for not using Twitter. Someone named Justin Bieber, who apparently is a teenage singer, was supposed to appear at the Roosevelt Field mall on Friday, but didn’t because the... Continue reading » Join the conversation...

  • Personal Finance Daily: Isn't there a better option than flex-spend plans?

    MarketWatch - 172 days 7 hours 8 minutes ago

    It's not nearly as flashy as the bickering over a proposed public-plan option or the confrontations that have broken out at some lawmakers' town hall meetings recently. But even the humble flexible spending account for health-care expenses, a tax-favored vehicle that many workers can elect to contribute to every year during open enrollment, is...

Links from the Web Buzz:
 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    lcmedia

    11/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Peter Pitts' CMPI Targeted Over Anti-Healthcare Reform Video Game

    Re: "Did anyone not know that Pitts works for both PN and CMPI?" (above).
    -----------------
    Apparently yes, Jim. Many people did not know that Peter Pitts, who presents himself as a "former FDA official," also has a role with a public relations company.

    Our show, The Infinite Mind, had Pitts on the air in 2008, as a former FDA official discussing the fact that Sen. Charles Grassley had pushed through an FDA "black box" warning on anti-depressants, in the absence of solid scientific evidence.

    We were not aware at the time of Pitts' PR connections, and failed to mention them on the air. Pitts' critics had a field day, even though, as I pointed out at the time, we were not alone: PBS' NewsHour and NPR also had Pitts on the air, and were also apparently unaware of his PR ties.

    Now, Pitts' PR connection is reported again as news, including last night on Rachel Maddow's MSNBC show. So to answer your question, yes, Jim, lots of people don't know that Pitts works for a non-profit advocacy group, and a PR company.

    We did not know it 18 months ago when The Infinite Mind was attacked for it, although Jeanne Lenzer at Slate, Philip Dawdy at Furious Seasons, and the other self-appointed "psychiatry critics" with ready access to blogs, had fun throwing mud, anyway. (At least you and BNET set the record straight: http://bit.ly/8lAi6S )

  •  
    2

    stephhunter

    11/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Peter Pitts' CMPI Targeted Over Anti-Healthcare Reform Video Game

    Just another ploy to scare people. The reality is that there won't be a rush on services. We've not seen that in places that already offer the public option. http://cli.gs/23yYaM/

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)