About Retail Industry

BNET Retail provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about the key players in the consumer retail industry. In addition to detailed retail company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new retailers, products, mergers and acquisitions, consumer spending figures, and a host of other important issues pertinent to the retail sector.

Staying on Top of Recession, Wal-Mart Adds Tesco-esque Financial Services

By Mike Duff | Feb 18, 2009

In the midst of a recession it is handling pretty well, Wal-Mart is establishing a financial services program for its customers with a particular emphasis on lower income consumers who might not have a checking account.

The move in financial services calls to mind Tesco in the United Kingdom, which offers insurance products, a savings program and personal loans. Tesco links financial services to store operations by offering a 50-pound gift card with car insurance, for example, and a loan payment protection plan providing, among other things, a 100-pound gift card and five Tesco.com home grocery deliveries each month that a claimant isn’t able to fulfill obligations. Wal-Mart, through its U.K. subsidiary ASDA, has had a clear view of how financial services have tied consumers to Tesco, although the breadth of its financial services have proven to have a challenging side in the economic downturn.

Wal-Mart’s plan is more focused and addresses problems confronted by an underserved demographic group former CEO Lee Scott considered at National Retail Federation convention in his final days as chief executive when he pointed out, “Twenty percent of our customers don’t have a checking account.” The lack may mean enduring long bill payment lines at utility offices and suffering exorbitant check cashing fees.

The Wal-Mart program centers on a $6 price reduction on the Walmart MoneyCard, a reloadable, pre-paid Visa debit card. Now for $3, consumers can deposit paychecks or other funds onto a card that allows them to settle bills through automated systems and to pay at stores that accept Visa debit.

Other charges apply. Reloads cost $3 and a $3 monthly fee is assessed, but that’s very competitive with fees for check cashing and bank checking services. Beyond that, direct deposits or those from paychecks transacted at Wal-Mart are not subject to the debit card reload fees, and customers who load at least $1,000 a month don’t have to shell out the periodic fee.

Wal-Mart once aspired to develop a banking business but existing financial institutions and certain members of Congress opposed the attempt, and the company eventually gave up. However, it has been adding financial services directed at certain lower income consumers including check cashing and wire transfers at prices that undercut many specialists in those businesses.

Wal-Mart is making what it can out of the recession. Just-announced fourth quarter earnings beat analyst expectations as U.S. sales gained six percent and comparables store sales advanced 2.8 percent. By adding additional financial services, Wal-Mart further positions itself as the store that’s doing what it can for hard pressed consumers even if they are employees, as workers get special deals on the cards.

Mike Duff has written about retail and related fields over 20 years. His work has appeared in publications as diverse as Retailing Today, Drug Store News, Supermarket Business, Consumer Digest, MarketingWeek, American Food and Ag Exporter magazines.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Dunnhumby Complicates Outlook for Tesco, Kroger, Wal-Mart

    BNET Retail - 314 days 4 hours 50 minutes ago

    Tesco is a mighty retailer, fourth largest in the world, but, even with its expansion in the United States continuing, it might not turn out to be the nightmare for Wal-Mart that some, particularly observers in Britain, expected it to be. Kroger, however, could turn into a nightmare. One of the major weapons Tesco employs in its United Kingdom...

  • Wal-Mart Focuses on Retaining Customers Beyond Recession

    BNET Retail - 193 days 10 hours 12 minutes ago

    Wal-Mart CEO Mike Duke is looking beyond the recession, placing emphasis in the companys first quarter conference call on its ability to retain high-income customers won during the recession. Not that hes predicting a rapid economic rebound. Rather, he noted that business improvements Wal-Mart has made and continues to make in the...

  • Wal-Mart's breather on lower prices

    Fortune - 102 days 4 hours 25 minutes ago

    NEW YORK (Fortune) -- Wal-Mart has won market share during the recession by relentlessly lowering prices -- a strategy echoed in its advertising slogan, "Save Money. Live Better." Now some analysts see signs that the giant retailer may be taking a momentary breather on the price lowering front -- and that could be good news for Target and other...

  • Rent-A-Center Beats Wal-Mart to Financial Services, Provides Warning

    BNET Retail - 277 days 6 hours 53 minutes ago

    Rent-A-Center has been getting a boost in the recession, seeing higher comparable store sales as consumers turn to it for furniture, appliances and electronics, but it has been tripped up a bit by an expansion into financial services, which might be an object lesson for Wal-Mart as it looks for new ways to serve lower income consumers....

  • Digging to the root of poverty among Indian farmers

    Financial Times - 164 days 23 hours 2 minutes ago

    A new Indian parliamentary committee report strikes a high-minded tone in the sensitive debate about allowing global retail groups such as Wal-Mart, Tesco and Carrefour to deepen their involvement in the Indian economy. The parliamentary committee on commerce this week warned of the exploitation of India's farmers that would occur if foreign...

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    Rogerbanana

    02/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Staying on Top of Recession, Wal-Mart Adds Tesco-esque Financial Services

    The inside story is that Walmart is struggling with their Walmart Money Card. Do the math and you can see why they slashed the price - to try to save the product.

    Here's my math: Walmart claims it has sold two million cards in two years, loading $2 billion US. If you do the math that's less than one card sold per day, per store. The average amount deposited onto the card is pathetic - less than $1000 US in total deposits per card (with an average deposit of $150 put on the card, that means people try it out for a month or two and drop it). Turnover is killing the product and Walmart is hoping that by slashing the price, they can reduce turnover.

    People are trying out the Walmart Money Card a few times, and then are deciding it is expensive and a hassle, and opening a bank account instead. Not what anyone would call a "success story?" (Imagine if the average Walmart store sold only one banana per store per day - they'd toss the banana out on its peel.)

  •  
    2

    bardmike

    02/24/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Staying on Top of Recession, Wal-Mart Adds Tesco-esque Financial Services

    Folks may not be lining up for the card and price may have had something to do with it. But banks can be a big problem for lower income consumers because they kill them with fees, some of which are difficult to understand in the first place. So, if Wal-Mart's going to succeed in this, it may need to put an extra effort into convincing customers its new fees represent a bargain when it compares with a bank account. Then again, not every consumer can open a bank account, but that's another kettle of fish. One of the reasons I brought up Tesco in the first place is to make the point that financial services are complex operations that don't always work out the way companies who are offering them would like. Which is a fact that looms large these days, and not just in the retail world.

    -- Mike

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Click Here
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement