About Technology Industry

BNET Technology provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about all aspects of the high-tech industry. In addition to detailed tech company profiles, we bring you industry analysis on new mergers and acquisitions, tech products, investments, patents, and a host of other important technology related business issues.

It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

By Erik Sherman | Aug 17, 2009

Suggesting that Steve Jobs leave his position at Apple is enough to rouse the wrath of the faithful, even though he was kicked out of the company once before. But no matter what good he may have done the company since his return, recently emerging behavior makes it clear that it is time for Jobs to find his fourth act after Apple, NeXT, and Pixar so he stops endangering the business that he built.

There was the well-documented liver transplant hormone imbalance. The rash of problems with overheating iPhones and iPods, with one unit even exploding, and Apple trying to hush up at least one victim as well as a reporter. There was having Google CEO Eric Schmidt on the board of directors while the two companies were clearly competitors. There is the behavior that the Times of London recently dubbed Bad Steve and Good Steve (via AppleInsider). Some of the stories (and granted there’s no dating many of them) are absolutely hair raising when you consider what you need in a chief executive:

One excessively strait-laced candidate for a job at Apple bored him so much, he sprang questions like “How old were you when you lost your virginity?” and “How many times have you taken LSD?” on the poor sap. (Jobs has said that taking LSD was one of the most important things in his own life.) Then he lapsed into a chant of “Gobble, gobble, gobble, gobble”. “I guess I’m not the right guy for this job,” said the candidate finally.

And then there’s the flip side:

But then there’s Good Steve. Abused employees, if they survive, often find themselves praised to the heavens. They ride on what is know as the “hero-asshole rollercoaster” and they live inside the “reality distortion field”, Jobs’s uncanny ability to convince people that the utterly impossible is, in fact, entirely possible.

Apparently Apple tried to get the paper to spike this story. You can see why.

The company can survive without Jobs. Apple can thrive without Jobs. In fact, it’s conceivable that the business could even do better at this point without Jobs. It did well enough with Jobs out on sick leave. It might do even better than that if it could excise the secrecy and manipulation that is seriously starting to limit it. One of the hardest things to manage about success is overstaying your welcome. Let Apple create little altars to give out to the faithful to keep the myth and let the man yield the stage.

Image via Flickr user blakespot, CC 2.0.

Erik Sherman is a freelance journalist whose work has appeared in Newsweek, the New York Times Magazine, Technology Review, the Financial Times, Chief Executive, and other publications. Follow him on Twitter.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Details murky as ailing Apple chief takes leave

    South China Morning Post - 309 days 18 hours 53 minutes ago

    Even as Apple Inc acknowledges that all is not well, the extent of Steve Jobs' health problems remains a closely guarded secret. The Apple chief executive, a cancer survivor, has revealed he is taking medical leave until June, a move that sent the company's shares plunging 7 per cent. Apple's chief operating officer, Tim Cook, will take over Mr...

  • MarketWatch First Take: Apple's iPhone price cut spells trouble for rivals

    MarketWatch - 165 days 21 hours 17 minutes ago

    The news out of Apple Inc.’s developer conference was what most investors had been expecting, even though some of the faithful had been hoping for even the briefest glimpse of chief executive Steve Jobs.

  • Will Apple's Next iPhone Have A Plastic Keyboard? No (AAPL)

    Silicon Alley Insider - 325 days 19 hours 53 minutes ago

    At some point, it seems likely that Apple (AAPL) will broaden its iPhone lineup to more than one design. But will the company sell an iPhone with a physical keyboard? Are there enough people out there who insist on an iPhone with plastic keys for Steve Jobs to get over his reported hatred of buttons? Anything's possible, but probably not. In...

  • Jobs Still Absent for WWDC

    Technologizer - 192 days 3 hours 5 minutes ago

    Even though Apple says that Steve Jobs will return to Apple in June, the company said on Wednesday that a “team of executives” led by Paul Schiller would give the keynote at the it’s Worldwide Developers Conference. While it does not directly say Jobs won’t be there, it seems to suggest that its unlikely he

  • Apple's Jobs to take medical leave of absence

    MarketWatch - 310 days 20 hours 55 minutes ago

    SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) -- Apple Inc. Chief Executive Steve Jobs said Wednesday that because of his health issues he will take a medical leave of absence from the company until the end of June. Jobs released a letter saying that Apple (AAPL:AAPLNews , chart , profile , moreLast:Delayed quote dataAdd to portfolioAnalystCreate...

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    conlad

    08/18/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    That's a dangerous proposition, but not because I'm a fanatic.

    What is Apple's real value and success? Radical Innovation. Can they do it without Jobs? Not if we judge by past history and what they did in their Jobs-less years.

    Would they be able to do it? That I guess is the real problem at hand, because no matter how bad is Jobs as an executive, he is a genius and all these problems will be forgotten when the next iPod or iPhone gets released (the much touted Tablet, maybe?).

    Also, never forget that companies live on the value they create, not how nice they act or how good a person their CEO is.

  •  
    2

    ErikSherman

    08/18/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    Basing a company on the presence of a single individual is even more dangerous, particularly when that individual has the medical history of Jobs. Either the company is robust enough to stand on its own, or it's incredibly over-valued and standing at the edge of a cliff because without the one individual it is incapable of success.

  •  
    3

    JeanSchaeffer

    08/18/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    I honestly believe that Jobs could be a bi-poloar manic despressive. Heavy on the mania side. He shows many of the signs. I can speak from my own experiences as a bi-polar. In the stage of maina I could be absolutley brilliant, out spoken beyond belief with no regrets or concerns. Then comes the other side... fortunately I'm medicated.

    Clearly, Apple can survive with him and it sounds like the work environment is descrutive for others in his shadow. I believe he should go, and the company should go on fostering inovation and treating people with respect.

  •  
    4

    conlad

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    Exactly Erik. Today's situation is not good as well, and I was just questioning Apple's ability to keep doing what they do without Jobs. Their years without him were mediocre at best, so what will happen once he leaves? You believe Apple is robust enough, or should be by this point, but I'm not so sure of that.

    And then, remember that Apple lives by making some very radical and powerful innovations, so for Jobs to step down means losing this huge creating force. Can Apple compensate with their current talent? Who knows, but so far competitors, like Nokia and Sony, have not been able to match Apple and it's my believe the reason is Jobs.

    I hope for Apple they do have a plan going. If not, perhaps your standing at the edge comparison is closest to the truth.

  •  
    5

    ErikSherman

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    Conlad, any company that cannot continue to exist without a particular CEO is an example of bad strategy and execution. And even though Jobs is listed as an inventor on 10 percent of their patents (mostly design patents), remember that much of the design is done by consulting firms.

  •  
    6

    jterrazas1

    10/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    Steve Job is the mastermind behind apples products at the moment. We need to leave him alone and see how far he can take this endeavor and offer great products for our comsumption.

    see www.ultimatesportband.com

  •  
    7

    ErikSherman

    10/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: It's Time for Jobs to Leave Apple

    So he gets a complete pass? I think not, unless you want to provide a pass to every other CEO. And to say that no such products could be developed without him is to say that they don't have a company if the particular CEO isn't there, which is a pretty sad statement.

  •  
    8

    connoblehill

    11/05/09 | Report as spam

    Don't kill the goose that lays the golden egg

    Whats wrong with a bit of madness? Smooth, silver tonque, shiny suit sales execs with maybe an MBA didn't make the company great - you can pick them up anywhere. The ideas, the passion, obsessional belief make the big ideas happen. Apple's appeal is that it is out there on the edge.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement
Click Here