ValueClick Exec Publicly Crucified Over E-Mail Error

Recommended Sources

About Advertising Industry

BNET Advertising provides daily industry trends and news coverage with insights for managers and executives about the major agencies in advertising, marketing, and public relations. In addition to detailed company and agency profiles, we bring you detailed industry analysis on new partnerships and acquisitions, ad buying and cost, new investments, inventory issues, and other issues critical to the marketing sector.

Mark Brown, a media development manager at ValueClick, is being crucified on the web simply for doing his job — trying to persuade sites to generate revenue for themselves by using his ad network. It’s all because he failed to check an email before hitting send.

Brown recently used the email contact form of ShoeMoney, a blog that covers web-based affiliate marketing. He wrote, “I’m wondering if you’d consider working with our company to help monetize you site’s ad inventory?”

Nothing controversial there. Unfortunately, Brown seems to have made an error in cutting and pasting his message, with the result that in addition to sending his pitch addressed to ShoeMoney, he also sent ShoeMoney an identical pitch addressed to MoneyExtra, a personal finance site.

No big deal, right? We’ve all done it.

Then ShoeMoney’s Jeremy Schoemaker put up an image of the email along with this commentary (errors are Schoemaker’s):

Mark Brown At ValueClick Fails At Spamming Contact Forms

I get unsolicited messages through the contact form… and of course… thats what its there for.

But when a publicly traded company fails this bad and spamming contact forms… Can you spot whats wrong ?

Now maybe its just me… but I would think the company who just settled a FTC lawsuit for 2.9 MILLION dollars for violating the Can Spam Act (the largest ever) and has pledged to completely change their spammy ways would be a little more careful. NAAAAAAAAH

ValueClick did indeed settle a spam action with the FTC in 2008 for that sum after the feds determined that its advertising claims and e-mails were deceptive and violated federal law. ValueClick had been promising “free” stuff that wasn’t free.

The Brown item has attracted 87 comments on ShoeMoney. It’s also been featured in a Twitter post, on StumbleUpon, and on SEO Bum.

The punishment seems to be disproportionate to the crime, especially compared to “Worst Twitter Post Ever” offender James Andrews.

Tags: Advertisement, ShoeMoney, Brown Item, E-mail, Online Communications, Jim Edwards

Jim Edwards, a former managing editor of Adweek, has covered drug marketing at Brandweek for four years, and is a former Knight-Bagehot fellow at Columbia University's business and journalism schools. Follow him on Twitter or send him an email.

BNET User Analysis

Voice your 2cents

Web Buzz:

ValueClick whacked over email; Commentors gleeful

Adotas - 283 days 9 hours 24 minutes ago

ADOTAS -- A ValueClick executive is not having a good week. A manager sent an email contact form to ShoeMoney, trying to solicit business. Unfortunately, the executive didn't read the email closely before sending, because pasted on it was the same message sent to MoneyExtra. Of course, ShoeMoney posted the email and whacked the executive,...
ValueClick *proposed settlement in shareholder lawsuit over ‘deceptive’ practices

Adotas - 72 days 8 hours 55 minutes ago

ADOTAS — While it now has an underperforming lead generation business, and with speculation it might be sold, a *recently proposed $10 million settlement in a lawsuit brought by shareholders, and the details of it, does not put ValueClick’s past practices in a good light. ValueClick denied the allegations at the time the lawsuit was filed....
False advertising lawsuit against ValueClick tossed

Adotas - 185 days 1 hour 5 minutes ago

ADOTAS — The online advertising company has been whacked before because of its advertising practices, but not this time. A California judge this week threw out a $45 million false advertising lawsuit against ValueClick that was brought by Internet service provider Hypertouch under a state law barring false and misleading commercial emails,...
Amazon acquires Zappos, the customer-friendly shoe company, for $807M$

VentureBeat - 108 days 4 hours 43 minutes ago

Amazon.com said it has agreed to acquire shoe retailer Zappos.com in a stock deal valued at $807 million. Zappos, which was founded in San Francisco during the tail end of the last Internet boom, became famous for its radically friendly customer service. You could order shoes, have them sent to you buy mail, try them on, and simply return them...
Judge sends $45 million spam lawsuit to junk folder

Ars Technica - 186 days 6 hours 38 minutes ago

A false advertising suit against ValueClick has been thrown out by a Los Angeles Superior Court Judge. Judge Richard Adler ruled this week that the Plaintiff, Hypertouch Inc., could not prove that fraud was involved in the commercial e-mail sent by ValueClick, resulting in a summary judgment in favor of the online advertiser. ...