advertisement
About Energy Industry

Business in the energy industry is fast paced and ever-changing. BNET Energy provides daily news coverage for managers and executives in the energy sector, with coverage on the major utilities, energy companies, clean tech and renewable energy businesses. BNET Energy offers in depth analysis of green business, the very latest in energy research, alliances and partnerships, competitive intelligence and a host of other global energy industry issues.

Researchers: Renewable Energy Jobs Are Safer

By Kirsten Korosec | Aug 20, 2009

The push for renewable energies has one more feather to put in its cap: improved health for its workforce and the potential of evading death, at least while on the job. 

As more workers shift from fossil fuel-related jobs to those in renewable energy, their health should improve, according to commentary by Medical College of Wisconsin researchers published in a recent issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

The researchers studied occupational health risks to workers in renewable energy and fossil fuel industries, according to a report by ScienceBlog. They found less risk of injury and death in wind and solar energy than in fossil fuel jobs. Biomass jobs did not have any significant safety benefit compared to fossil fuels.

The study, which was partially supported by a grant from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, notes the passage of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act has put more money towards renewable energy. This added investment will shift more workers away from fossil fuels and in turn, improve their overall health, the study says.

So what does this mean for the 700,000 folks working in the energy sector? Well, one of the researchers, Steven Sumner said this in the Scienceblog post:

“The energy sector remains one of the most dangerous industries for U.S. workers. A transition to renewable energy generation utilizing sources such as wind and solar could potentially eliminate 1,300 worker deaths over the coming decade.”

Researchers noted the lack of more precise data on renewable energy occupations. Still, they found that while fossil fuels are traditionally cheaper than renewable energy, “hidden costs” including the negative effects on health have not been figured in.

Other tidbits:

  • Mining coal, gas and oil from underground or underwater stores is the second most hazardous job in the U.S. with 27.5 death per 100,000 compared to the average annual fatality rate of 3.4 deaths in all U.S. industries;
  • Highway crashes account for the greatest proportion of death among oil and gas extraction workers;
  • Solar, wind and fossil fuels need to access transmission lines to get their source of power to households and businesses. Those industries share the risk of accident from electrical current traveling through power lines.

Image of Safety First sign from Flickr user Heathervescent, CC 2.0

Kirsten Korosec has been a print and online journalist for more than 10 years covering education, politics and business.

BNET User Analysis

Web Buzz:
  • Dell and Envision Solar refashion parking lot into clean energy farm, EV recharge station (video)

    Engadget - 28 days 12 hours 55 minutes ago

    Dell has added a shiny new feather to its cap today with the announcement of a freshly completed Solar Grove renewable energy installation. The system is composed of 512 solar panels, which provide shelter for 56 cars, and are capable of harvesting 131,000 kWh of energy per year. This power will be primarily used in the adjacent Round Rock HQ,...

  • Origin acquires Wind Power

    The Australian - 201 days 10 hours 1 minute ago

    ORIGIN Energy, Australia's second biggest electricity and gas retailer, has acquired Wind Power, more than tripling its potential wind capacity to benefit from regulations supporting renewable energy. Along with existing sites and options, the purchase increases Origin's prospective capaase Increase Developing all the projects may cost as much...

  • The White House Speaks Up for a Carbon Cap

    TreeHugger - 47 days 6 hours 21 minutes ago

    Photo via SMH There's been some talk in the Senate about splitting a climate bill up into two bills; one that would set renewable energy targets, and one that would establish a cap and trade. There's also been some unfortunate nods towards eliminating a carbon cap from a bill altogether--an idea pushed by an influential Democrat, no less. But...

  • Company rolls out the red carpet for Cameron visit

    Belfast - 181 days 12 hours 37 minutes ago

    Ulster Carpets got a feather in its cap last week when Conservative leader David Cameron included the Portadown company in the itinerary of his one-day visit to Northern Ireland. Mr Cameron was given a guided tour and said he was impressed by the company’s record of investment and commitment to research and development. The Tory leader, who...

  • Brazilâ??s hard-to-tap oil fields raising concerns

    MSNBC - 91 days 7 hours 42 minutes ago

    RIO DE JANEIRO - Brazil, long proud of its push to develop renewable energy and wean itself off oil, has a bad case of fossil-fuel fever. An enormous offshore field in territorial waters — the biggest Western Hemisphere oil discovery in 30 years — has Brazilians saying, "Drill, baby, drill," while environmentalists fear the nation will take...

Links from the Web Buzz:
 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    exaviator

    08/24/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Researchers: Renewable Energy Jobs Are Safer

    Interesting, but while I certainly respect U of W, I'm not certain they have a solid enough data base from the "green" world nor the correct proxy for measurement.

    First of all, the data from the fossil fuel industry is long and deep. I'm too cheap to buy the paper from JAMA, but the statistic "27.5 deaths per 100000" tells me right away they may be examining staatistics differently. OSHA (U.S. -- similar sort of measurement in E.U.)generally uses an "incident per 100 man-yr" statistic for recordable injury (200,000 m-hr equals 100 m-yr). If you are a contractor working on refinery property you know that a Total Recordable incident Rate (TRIR) of more than 2 or 3 will generally keep you from coming in the gates, so I don't know where "27.5" comes from. By the way, if you use the recordable numbers from Valero, Mobil and Citgo, you will probably get the injury statistics for convenience store workers included (which are WORSE than refinery and processing) since they still own a number of stores.

    Furthermore, they didn't put anything in the press release (not the fault of the Ms. Korosec) about the extraordinary safety of nuclear facilities. In the U.S. the average TRIR for A real estate agent is higher than for a nuclear facility worker. Areva and their customers do even better than we do here. I can't imagine wind and solar numbers look this good.

    Finally, once we have a significant installed base of wind and solar, with "working aloft" requirements, multiple DC sources on a grid, and realistic maintenance rates on mature hardware, then we'll be able to compare legitimate numbers.

    And I think a better measurement would be TRIR per MW-hr. The average wind turbine has a HUGE number of workers involved in construction for a relatively small amount of power, and with a capacity factor in the 30's (20's for wind) the amount of power produced per worker is not very high.

  •  
    2

    kirsten korosec

    08/25/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Researchers: Renewable Energy Jobs Are Safer

    Interesting points. I too wonder about the "working aloft" requirements in wind and solar.

    After reading through the recent stimulus funding updates from DOE, I was struck by the number environmental management projects there were. I wonder what the safety records are for those types of jobs. It's not really an energy industry job, although it's certainly related.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement